For my birthday, my sister Ashley gave me a ten-dollar scratch-off ticket. I won two hundred bucks. And my mother’s face fell apart. She snatched the ticket out of my hand, her knuckles white. "This is Ashley’s luck! You give this back to her, and I’ll buy you a new one." I was stunned. "Mom, I’m the one who scratched it..." "Why do you have to be so selfish?" Her voice shot up, sharp and accusing. "Do you know what your sister makes an hour? This is a week's worth of groceries for her!" Ashley, scrolling through her phone, didn’t even look up. "Whatever, Mom. Let her have it. It's her birthday present." My mother’s eyes instantly welled with tears. "You see? Look how considerate your sister is! And then there's you, using your own birthday to take advantage of her!" I felt a cold wave wash over me. Just last month, for Ashley’s birthday, my mother had insisted I buy her a Tiffany bracelet. When Ashley got it, she didn’t even say thank you. Suddenly, the brand-new designer purse I’d bought for my mom, sitting in my bag, felt ridiculously out of place. It looked like she wouldn’t be getting it after all. 1. The candles on my cake were barely lit when Ashley tossed a crumpled scratch-off ticket onto the table. "Here," she said. "Happy birthday. Go on, scratch it. If you win, you have to thank me." I found a penny and scraped away the silver coating. The number "$200" appeared. "Wow, I won!" I looked up, smiling, only to see the joy drain from my mother’s face. She snatched the ticket, gripping it so tightly her nails dug into the thin cardboard. "This is Ashley’s luck! Give it back to her. I’ll buy you another one." I just stared at her. "Mom, she gave it to me. I scratched it…" "Don’t be so selfish, Sarah!" she snapped, her voice cracking. "Ashley’s barely making ends meet. Two hundred dollars is a lot of money for her!" Ashley, still glued to her phone, sighed dramatically. "It’s fine, Mom. Just let her have it." That was all it took for my mom to get choked up. "Look at your sister, so generous! And you, you have to make a big deal on your birthday and take from her!" Last month, for Ashley's 24th birthday, my mother had taken me aside. "Sarah, honey," she’d said, her voice dripping with concern, "Ashley needs something real for her birthday. A milestone. All her friends have nice things. You’re doing so well, you should get her something that will last." She kept this up for a month. Daily calls and texts about how hard Ashley had it, how I was the big sister, how I could easily afford it. I caved. I spent three thousand dollars on a classic Tiffany & Co. bracelet. When I gave it to her, Ashley ripped the box open and immediately clasped it onto her wrist, not even bothering with the tissue paper. "Mom! Look!" She wiggled her arm, the silver catching the light. "It fits perfectly!" My mom beamed, adjusting it for her. "It’s beautiful! You have such delicate wrists, everything looks good on you." Ashley threw her arms around Mom. "Thanks, Mom!" I was left standing there, holding the empty blue box. My mom patted Ashley's back, then glanced at me. "See? She loves it." Ashley finally looked at me and gave a dismissive little smile. "Oh, yeah. It’s nice." Then she went right back to admiring her wrist. Not a single "thank you" was directed at me. "The quality is just wonderful," Mom murmured, turning Ashley’s hand over and over. "She can wear this for the rest of her life…" I quietly put the empty box in my purse. The crinkle of the wrapping paper was the only sound I made. "Oh, right," my mother said, as if suddenly remembering I was there. "Sarah, make sure you give Ashley the receipt. In case she wants to exchange it for a different style…" "I will," I said, my voice flat. Ashley finally tore her eyes away from the bracelet and held her hand out to me. "Receipt?" I pulled the slip of paper from my wallet. She plucked it from my fingers and stuffed it into the pocket of her jeans. "So, what’s for dinner?" she asked, linking her arm through Mom’s. "I'm craving sushi." "Of course, sweetie," Mom said instantly, then turned to me. "You want to come?" I looked at the gleaming bracelet on my sister's wrist, and a heavy, sinking feeling settled in my stomach. "No, thanks," I said, grabbing my bag. "I have a brief to finish up for work." As I was walking out the door, I heard Ashley ask, "Why does she always have to be such a downer?" The door clicked shut, cutting off my mother's sympathetic laughter. 2. Staring at the flickering candles on my cake, I replayed that scene in my head and felt like an idiot. What was I even expecting? I touched my purse, feeling the smooth leather of the Chanel handbag inside. It cost a fortune. My birthday is also the day my mom went through hell to have me, and I wanted to give her something special, a real nest egg. Since Ashley had her Tiffany, I thought Mom deserved something even better. But now? No. I was keeping it for myself. My mother was still going on. "Your sister has it so tough. As the older sister, can't you just let her have this one thing?" That sentence was the match that lit a thirty-year-old powder keg. All the times I had swallowed my pride and my hurt… I was done. I am thirty years old. I’ve spent three decades letting things go. This time, I wasn’t going to. "Let her have it? Haven't I let her have enough?!" My voice was so loud it startled me. My mom stared, speechless. Ashley finally looked up from her phone, her expression one of pure shock. "From the day she was born, what haven't I given her? Toys, clothes, my room, my opportunities… and now I’m supposed to give her my winning lottery ticket?!" I snatched it back from her hand and clenched it in my fist. "She has it so tough? Then how could she accept a three-thousand-dollar bracelet from me without so much as a thank you?!" My mother's face hardened. "Now you're keeping score…" "Keeping score?!" I laughed, a bitter sound. "You didn't seem to mind when I was spending three grand on her! But over two hundred dollars, you call me selfish?" Ashley rolled her eyes. "God, Sarah, what's the big deal? It’s just a scratch-off ticket." "It is a big deal!" I spun to face her. "Of course it's not a big deal to you! You’re always the one getting everything handed to you!" My mother’s face was pale with rage, her finger trembling as she pointed at me. "How dare you speak to your sister like that!" "Oh, I'm just getting started," I said, taking a deep breath and speaking each word with cold precision. "From this day on, I’m not giving up another damn thing." With that, I grabbed my purse and walked out. "You get back here!" she shrieked behind me. "What is this attitude!" I slammed the door without looking back. In the hallway, I could hear Ashley's syrupy voice. "Mom, don't be mad. You know how she gets…" I stood at the elevator, jamming the ‘down’ button over and over, desperate to escape the house that had been draining the life out of me for my entire life. 3. I’m six years older than Ashley. My mother had a complicated delivery with her. A hemorrhage. She almost died on the operating table. She always said Ashley was a miracle, a gift from God that had to be protected. So Ashley became the center of her universe. A delicate doll to be cherished and shielded from the world. And I became the older sister who always had to step aside. When I was in elementary school, I won first prize in the school’s academic fair. The prize was a brand-new, bright red backpack. I loved it. Ashley, who was in preschool, decided she had to have it. My mom didn’t even ask. She just started pulling it off my shoulders. "Your sister wants it. You’re older, you can use your old one." I clutched the straps. "But I won it…" Smack. The sting on my cheek was sharp and immediate. "Do you have any idea what I went through to give you that sister?" my mom screamed, her eyes red. "I almost died! My back has never been the same! You ungrateful child!" I have so many memories like that, but the one that sticks with me the most was the Disneyland trip. I was ten, Ashley was four. She threw a massive tantrum, screaming and crying that she had to go. My mom finally gave in. I stood by the door, twisting the strap of my schoolbag. "Mom, can I come too?" She didn't look up from braiding Ashley’s hair. "And do what? Do you know how much a ticket costs? We can’t afford to take you both. You need to be more responsible. You can stay home and do Ashley's laundry." I bit my lip. "But I have homework..." "Do it tonight!" she snapped, slamming the hairbrush on the table. "Your sister rarely asks for anything. Can’t you be considerate for once?" My eyes burned. "Why do I always have to be the one? Why do you never take me anywhere? Don't you love me?" She shot up, her hand raised to hit me again. "Don't I love you? How do you think you got this far, you ungrateful little—" My dad stepped in, guiding her away and shooting me a look. "Your mom's just stressed, Sarah. Don't make it worse. We'll bring you back a souvenir." After they left, I stood in the empty living room and cried until I couldn't breathe. And after I was done crying, I started to believe it was my fault. That I really was inconsiderate. So I washed all of Ashley's clothes. I mopped the floors. I even scrubbed the greasy stove top. I thought that when they came home and saw how clean everything was, they’d finally praise me. That afternoon, I heard the key in the lock and ran to the door. Ashley burst in, waving a new teddy bear, and immediately tripped over a small stool I’d used for cleaning. She fell and started wailing. My mom rushed over, scooped Ashley up, and then turned and shoved me, hard. "Did you push her?! You are a vicious child! Just because we didn't take you to Disneyland?" I stumbled back against the wall, my shoulder aching. "I didn't! She tripped!" "Liar!" Mom raised her hand again. "You've been jealous of your sister since the day she was born!" I flinched, tears streaming down my face. It wasn't until a terrified Ashley whimpered, "...it was the stool..." that Mom lowered her hand. But her expression only got uglier. "Well, it's your fault for leaving the stool in the middle of the room!" That night, I cried myself to sleep. In my mother's eyes, I was always wrong. Her guilt over nearly dying to have Ashley had been forged into a weapon. And she used it on me, every single day. My dad’s refrain was always the same: "Your mother has it hard. You have to understand." But who was supposed to understand me? Maybe from the day my mom almost died, I was destined to be the sacrifice. My hurt was meant to soothe her guilt. My surrender was meant to fix her trauma. But why? Because I was born six years earlier? Because I grew up healthy and without complication? From then on, I buried myself in books. It was the only place I could win. When I got the best grades, teachers praised me. When I won competitions, my classmates were impressed. It was the only time I felt like I was worthy of being loved. 4. Thankfully, I was a good student. All those years of feeling invisible, I channeled that pain into my studies. I fought and clawed my way into a top law school. The day I graduated, I stood on the stage in my cap and gown, accepting an award for academic excellence. The auditorium was filled with applause, but the one person I wanted to see wasn't there. She was at Ashley’s high school for a parent-teacher conference. After I started my career, I rarely went home. That house was a museum of my pain: Ashley’s stolen toys, my mother’s dismissive glare, my father’s weak, placating smile. Every visit felt like suffocating. But last Christmas, my aunt convinced me to go home. When I opened the door, I was shocked. My mother's hair was so much grayer, like a dusting of snow. The moment she saw me, her eyes filled with tears, and she grabbed my arm with her thin, frail hands as if she was afraid I’d vanish. At dinner, she kept piling my plate with my favorite foods. She remembered. Later, my dad pulled me onto the porch. "Your mother..." he began, his voice thick. "She stays up some nights, just looking at your old childhood photos." He sighed. "I think she knows she was wrong." In the moonlight, I could see the glint of tears in his eyes. In that moment, my resolve softened. Ashley was away at college out of state. My parents were alone. I started visiting every week. I bought my mom expensive supplements and took my dad for a full physical. Mom would stroke my cheek and say, "My oldest girl is the best." I thought we had finally turned a corner. I thought we could be a normal family, and I craved that long-overdue affection. Until the day Ashley graduated and moved back home, dragging her suitcases behind her.
? Continue the story here ?? ? Download the "MotoNovel" app ? search for "385451", and watch the full series ✨! #MotoNovel