The Mermaid Tail She Drowned In

My boyfriend and my best friend told me they were going to cure my aquaphobia. For my birthday, they bought me a custom silicone mermaid tail. "Put it on and you're a mermaid, Izzy. How can a mermaid be afraid of water?" Amanda smiled warmly as she helped me slide into the tight silicone tail. She zipped it up to my waist, binding my legs together completely. Before I could even process what was happening, Charlie shoved me into the six-foot-deep end of the pool. The silicone tail flooded instantly, dragging me down like a block of concrete. I thrashed desperately, my fingers scraping against the rough pool wall, splitting two of my fingernails down to the quick. As the chlorinated water rushed up my nose, I heard Amanda laughing on the deck, completely breathless. "Look at her! Oh my god, she looks like a stranded catfish!" Charlie crouched by the edge, holding his phone, adjusting the angle for her. "Alright, that’s enough. Get the video, then pull her up." But he didn’t jump in. I choked on water, my knees slamming against the concrete bottom. It was a stranger who finally plunged in and dragged me out. Amanda was already swiping through her camera roll, tears of laughter in her eyes. "That was perfect! Next time we go to the beach, you won’t be scared at all, I promise." Charlie patted my back, repeating his usual refrain. "Alright, let's not make it so intense next time." But every "next time" was just the opening act for Amanda’s next round of amusement. I knelt on the edge of the pool, coughing up water, my vision blurred, feeling like I was trapped in a giant glass fishbowl. Even the weakest person has to learn how to drag themselves ashore. Don't they? …… 1 "Charlie, look at her. She looks like one of those belly-up goldfish on TikTok." Amanda squatted in front of me, shoving her phone in my face, looping the video of me drowning. I gripped the wet tile of the pool deck, my throat burning with acid and chlorine. The silicone tail was still bound tightly around my legs, heavy and suffocating, like a pair of underwater shackles. Charlie finally walked over. He knelt beside me, gently brushing my wet hair away from my face. "Izzy, drink some warm water." He poured some water from his thermos, his fingers warm, his touch incredibly tender. But just moments ago, he had stood six feet away, watching me sink, and hadn't moved an inch. "Charlie," my voice was raw, barely a whisper. "Why didn't you jump in?" He blinked, a flicker of defensive evasion crossing his eyes. "I thought you could get out on your own. It wasn't that deep." Amanda chimed in, her tone light, as if talking about the weather. "Exactly, Izzy, don't be dramatic. It's only six feet. I was diving in the deep end in elementary school." She reached down to unzip the tail, her long acrylic nail scraping against my split fingernail. A sharp, blinding pain shot up my arm. I flinched, pulling my leg back. "Jeez, stop moving," she frowned. "I'm trying to help you, and you're acting like I'm hurting you." Charlie patted her hand away and took over the zipper. "Let me do it. Her hand is bleeding." The way he leaned down, completely focused and careful, made him look like the perfect boyfriend. But staring at the back of his head, a cold dread settled deep in my chest. Twenty-one years. Ever since I fell into the town reservoir at five years old and had to be dragged out, half-dead, I hadn't touched deep water. Charlie knew that. Amanda knew that. They knew every detail. "Izzy," Amanda smiled again, slipping her phone into her purse. "I'm keeping this video. Once you're 'cured,' we can do a before-and-after post. It'll go viral." I didn't say anything, watching Charlie finally slide the heavy silicone off my ankles. My calves were marked with deep red welts, the skin pale and shriveled from the water. The stranger who had pulled me out was still standing a few yards away, looking uncertainly at us. Charlie noticed, stood up, and gave him a polite, charming nod. "Thanks, man. My boyfriend duties were slacking. Appreciate the help." The guy looked at me, then at the beaming Amanda. He opened his mouth, thought better of it, and walked away. I wanted to laugh. Panicked easily. It was always those two words, draped over everything like a cheap sheet to cover up the ugly truth. "Come on," Charlie said, helping me up. "I'll drive you home. It's your birthday. We're going to that Italian place you love." Amanda slipped her arm through his other one, as naturally as if she owned it. "Yeah, Izzy. Charlie made reservations, and I'm coming along to celebrate you properly." I stood there, my legs trembling, water dripping from the ends of my hair. "Charlie, how much did that tail cost?" He paused, caught off guard. "Why do you ask? About five hundred dollars. It's custom medical-grade silicone." "Five hundred dollars," I repeated. "To push me into a pool." Amanda's smile faltered for a fraction of a second before smoothing over. "Izzy, that's unfair. We're trying to help you face your fears, not hurt you." "Yeah," Charlie agreed, gently ruffling my wet hair. "We only want what's best for you." What's best for you. I looked at the two of them standing side by side, the world blurring around the edges. "Sure," I said quietly. "Then next time, maybe find a different way to care about me." Charlie let out a breath, his easy smile returning. "Deal. We won't make it so intense next time." There it was again. That empty promise. 2 During the ride back, I leaned my head against the cool glass of the passenger window, Charlie’s dry jacket draped over my shivering legs. Charlie was driving. Amanda sat in the passenger seat. They were talking about the upcoming office retreat, laughing easily. I closed my eyes, the chemical smell of chlorine still burning my throat, dragging me back to when I was five. That summer, we had gone to the reservoir with the adults. Amanda wasn't "Amanda" to me back then. She went by "Mae," the foster kid living next door, a year older than me. She told me there were shiny shells clinging to the concrete lip of the dam. She coaxed me to crouch over the edge. And then, her hand pressed into my back. I remember it with terrifying clarity. It was a push—not a slip, not an accident. A deliberate, forceful shove. As I plunged into the dark water, I heard her screaming for help from the bank, her voice frantic, tearing at her throat. When the adults finally dragged me out, everyone praised Mae for her quick thinking, for saving my life by calling out. No one believed a terrified five-year-old who claimed her friend had pushed her. My mother had even slapped my face, telling me to stop lying and trying to ruin a good girl's reputation. Since then, I’ve been terrified of deep water. And I learned a bitter lesson: No one believes me. "Izzy, we're here," Charlie's voice broke through the memory. I opened my eyes to the harsh neon sign of the restaurant. Inside the private dining room, several of Charlie's coworkers and Amanda's friends were already seated. The moment I walked in, someone whistled. "Hey, look, the mermaid's here! How was the big performance in the pool today?" Laughter erupted around the table. Amanda laughed loudest, pulling out her phone. "Oh, you have to see the live footage. Izzy was an absolute star." The video played again. My choking, thrashing figure reflected in the glowing faces around the table. The laughter felt like needles, pricking my skin. Charlie sat beside me, ignoring the screen, placing a piece of chicken onto my plate. "You've been losing weight, Izzy. Eat up." He was always so flawless. Attentive, gentle, leaving me with no room to express anger without looking like a hysterical child. "Charlie is seriously too good to you," one of Amanda's friends sneered. "If my girlfriend was this much of a buzzkill, I’d have dumped her ages ago." Buzzkill. I stared at the food on my plate, my appetite completely gone. "Oh, Izzy," Amanda said suddenly, as if remembering something. "The company retreat is next month at the Outer Banks. You and Charlie have to come." "The Outer Banks?" "Yeah! It's the perfect chance to finish your therapy. A swim in the ocean, and your phobia will be gone for good." My hand tightened around my fork. "I'm not going." The room fell quiet. Amanda’s smile dimmed. "Izzy, don't be like that. Everyone is just trying to help." "I don't need this kind of help," I said, looking up. "Every time you have an idea, I'm the one who ends up suffering." Under the table, Charlie squeezed my hand. His grip was soft but firm, a silent warning to keep the peace. "Izzy, Amanda is just worried about you. If you don't face this, how are we going to travel or do anything in the future?" Amanda. Since when did he speak about her with such soft, familiar concern? "Charlie," I looked him in the eye. "What did you just call her?" He blinked. "Her name. What's wrong with that?" Amanda chimed in with a sweet laugh. "Izzy, don't be paranoid. Charlie and I went to the same college before he ever met you. We've known each other forever." Known each other forever. It sounded harmless, but a wire snapped tight in my chest. I had known her since I was five. I met Charlie when I was twenty-three. When she said "forever," what timeline was she actually talking about? 3 Despite my protests, Charlie coaxed me into going to the coastal retreat. "Just come for me," he promised. "You don't have to touch the water. You can just relax on the beach. I promise." I believed him, because he always made promises. The first two days were quiet. I sat on a lounge chair, watching them swim from a safe distance. But on the third night, there was a bonfire by the marina. Amanda, flushed with wine, staggered over and grabbed my arm. "Izzy, come on. We're playing a game. Super simple." She dragged me onto the wooden pier. Below us, the high tide surged, black and heavy. "What game?" I asked, pulling back. "Truth or Dare. If you lose, you jump in for a quick lap," she said, her eyes crinkling. I immediately turned around. "I'm not playing." She grabbed my wrist, her grip surprisingly strong for someone who claimed to be drunk. "Don't be a party pooper, Izzy. Charlie already agreed. He said it would be good for you." I looked back at Charlie. He stood by the bonfire, holding a beer, smiling at me. "Come on, Izzy, just give it a try. Amanda's right there with you." A crowd of coworkers had gathered on the narrow pier. Amanda suddenly raised her voice, addressing everyone. "Did you guys know Izzy fell into a reservoir when she was five? She's been terrified of water ever since. So tragic, right?" My face burned with humiliation. "Amanda, shut up." "What did I say wrong?" she gasped, looking hurt. "I'm just helping you open up. Keeping it bottled up is why you aren't getting better." She threw her arm around my shoulder, leaning in close, playing the doting sister. But a second later, I felt the hand on my shoulder shift, pushing weight outward toward the edge of the pier. The exact same pressure, the exact same trajectory as twenty-one years ago. My blood ran ice cold. "Amanda," I hissed, grabbing the wooden railing with both hands. "You're trying to push me again." "Push you?" Her eyes widened, her voice instantly cracked with tears. "Izzy, how could you say that? I was holding onto you because I thought you were slipping!" Whispers broke out among the coworkers. They looked at me like I was a paranoid lunatic. Charlie hurried over, pulling me away from the railing. "Izzy, calm down! Why would Amanda push you?" "It was her! Twenty-one years ago, she pushed me into the reservoir, too!" My voice shook violently. Amanda burst into tears, looking like a victim of a terrible slander. "I knew it! You've hated me all this time! You slipped on your own back then, and I was the one who screamed for help!" "Charlie," she turned to him, sobbing. "She always accuses me of trying to kill her. What did I ever do to deserve this? We grew up together..." Charlie sighed, stepping in front of Amanda to shield her. "Izzy, that was decades ago. Let it go. Amanda has carried that guilt for years, and she was just a kid too." Guilt. I looked at how naturally he protected her, how practiced it felt. One of the coworkers shook their head. "His girlfriend is so toxic." "Imagine attacking someone who’s just trying to help." I stood on the pier, shivering in the ocean breeze. Twenty-one years later, I was standing alone against the world again. No one believed me. Suddenly, I didn't want to explain anymore. "Charlie," I said softly, looking at him. "You believe her, not me." He hesitated, reaching out to touch my arm. "Izzy, it's not that I don't believe you..." "Then you jump," I interrupted. "Jump in and swim a lap. Prove to me the water is perfectly safe." His hand froze in midair. "I... I can't swim." The pier went dead silent. I let out a cold laugh. "You can't swim." "That day at the pool... you couldn't swim either." "So when you watched me sink, it wasn't that you didn't want to save me. You couldn't." 4 After we got back from the coast, the insomnia started. The realization that he couldn't swim festered in my mind. He knew he couldn't save me, yet he let me be pushed into a six-foot pool, gambling that someone else would step in. He gambled with my life just to keep up his facade. I started searching through Charlie's things. Not to catch him cheating, but because I needed to find the missing pieces. In his study, in a drawer beneath some tax documents, I found an old photo album. Inside were photos of him and Amanda. The dates were meticulously labeled. The earliest was from fifteen years ago. Two teenagers standing outside a middle school. Charlie wore braces; Amanda had her hair in a high ponytail, smiling brightly. On the back, a line written in faded ink: "Mae's birthday. Love, Charlie." Mae. My hands began to shake. Amanda's childhood nickname was Mae. She had known Charlie for fifteen years. And she had told me they met through work just a couple of years ago. I kept flipping through the pages and found a stack of letters written by Amanda to Charlie. The most recent was dated just a week before our trip to the pool. "Charlie, once we handle the situation with Izzy, make sure the deed to the condo is put in my name." "She’s so terrified of water. A little accident in the pool, and no one will question it, right?" I collapsed onto the floor, my limbs turning to ice. The pool incident wasn't an aggressive form of exposure therapy. It was a rehearsal. They wanted me to "accidentally" drown so they could inherit the downtown condo my father had left me. It was a fully paid-off property, solely in my name, left to me after my father passed. During our two years of dating, Charlie had constantly pressured me to add his name to the title. I had refused, because it was the only piece of my father I had left. They simply couldn't wait any longer. I took photos of every page in the album and every single letter. Then I put everything back exactly as I found it. I sat in the dark study until the sun came up. When morning broke, my mind was made up. I opened my laptop and logged into a portal I hadn't touched in months. Three months ago, I had received a job offer from a marine research institute in Norway. I had been too terrified to accept. The position required living on a research vessel in the North Sea. I, the girl who couldn't stand the sight of a swimming pool, had applied for a job surrounded by miles of open ocean. Perhaps, subconsciously, I had been trying to escape long before this. I opened the email and typed a single word in my reply. "Accept." Over the next week, I dismantled my life in total silence. I resigned from my job, ended the lease on my small studio, and changed the locks on my father's condo. Most importantly, I paid a visit to a trust attorney. I had the photos of the album and the letters officially notarized, leaving a copy with my lawyer. Charlie and Amanda had no idea. That entire week, Charlie was frustratingly sweet. He drove me everywhere, bought me flowers, and acted like the doting partner. Amanda stopped bringing up the beach trip, acting as sweet as a lamb. They were waiting for me to soften, waiting for me to finally sign the deed over to Charlie. The day I left was a Wednesday. I told Charlie I had a three-day business trip out of state. He didn't suspect a thing. He drove me to the airport, helped me with my bags, and kissed my forehead. "Hurry back," he murmured. "I'll be waiting." I stared at his face—the face of the man I had once believed I would grow old with. "Charlie," I asked quietly. "When did you stop loving me?" He blinked, startled. "Izzy, what are you talking about? Of course I love you." "What do you love about me?" He opened his mouth, then closed it. "You're... you're a good person. Sweet, sensible." Sensible. The ultimate compliment for an obedient pet. I offered him a faint smile, turned around, and walked toward security without looking back. Right before the plane took off, I sent him one final text. Then I turned off the phone, discarded the SIM card, and deactivated my social media accounts. When I landed in Oslo to board the small propeller plane to the North Sea research station, I looked out the window at the endless expanse of gray-blue water. The abyss I had feared for twenty-one years lay beneath me, vast and silent. And somehow, the terror was gone. At that very moment, Charlie was standing outside the door of my locked condo. He was staring at his phone, reading my final text for the seventh time. It read: "I've donated the condo to a children's crisis charity. You and Amanda can figure out how to split the rest." He tried calling me frantically, but all he got was the cold, automated operator. "We're sorry, the number you have dialed is no longer in service."

? Continue the story here ?? ? Download the "MotoNovel" app ? search for "542305", and watch the full series ✨! #MotoNovel